The Criminal District and County Court at Law Judges of Travis County (hereinafter referred to as the “Criminal Court Judges”) are committed to providing timely and quality legal representation to indigent criminal defendants, to guaranteeing fair and neutral procedures for attorney selection, and ensuring that minimum competency standards for court-appointed attorneys are established, while striving to wisely expend public funds.  In accordance with the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter referred to as "TCCP"), the Criminal Court Judges have adopted these rules, the Travis County Fair Defense Plan (hereinafter referred to as The Plan) to ensure compliance with the above state goals and principles.  

A.       When the Right to Appointed Counsel Attaches 

1.            If the defendant is arrested pursuant to a warrant, the detaining authority must present the defendant before the magistrate within 48 hours of arrest. 

2.            If the defendant is arrested without a warrant for a misdemeanor and a magistrate has not determined probable cause, the defendant must be released on bond, not to exceed $5,000, no later than 24 hours after arrest.  

3.            If the defendant is arrested without a warrant for a felony and a magistrate has not determined probable cause, the defendant must be released on bond, not to exceed $10,000, no later than 48 hours after arrest. 

4.            If the prosecutor files an application, a magistrate may postpone the release of the defendant for no more than 72 hours after arrest.

 

B.       Magistration of Defendants Arrested WITH OR WITHOUT a Warrant 

1.            Persons in custody brought before a magistrate shall be informed by the magistrate of the right to request counsel under TCCP Article 15.17 Subsection (e) and (f).  A record will be made of these proceedings and shall be preserved as required by TCCP Article 15.17.  

2.            If the arrested person does not speak or understand the English language or is deaf, the magistrate shall ensure that the information and assistance are provided with the assistance of an interpreter consistent with TCCP Articles 38.30 and 38.31.  

3.            If the defendant asks that an attorney be appointed, the magistrate shall instruct a pretrial services officer to assist the defendant in filling out the Indigence Application and request for appointed counsel.               

4.            A pretrial services officer shall interview a defendant in jail after arrest to determine personal bond status AND collect information regarding a person’s ability to pay for an attorney.  If the defendant requests appointed counsel, pretrial staff will provide the defendant with reasonable assistance filling out the Indigence Application in accordance with Criminal Court Judges’ instructions and protocol. If a defendant does not request and meet the qualifications to receive an appointed attorney, the person will sign and date the Indigence Application at the appropriate top section indicating counsel is not requested. TCCP Article 17.033. 

5.            For a defendant arrested on an out-of-county warrant, the magistrate must ask if the defendant wants to request counsel, inform the defendant of the procedures for requesting counsel, and ensure the defendant is provided reasonable assistance in completing the necessary forms for requesting counsel in the county issuing the warrant [Art. 15.18(a-1), CCP] 

6.            Requests for counsel made by defendants arrested on out-of-county warrants must be transmitted to the appointing authority of the county issuing the warrant within 24 hours of the request being made. [Art. 15.18(a-1), CCP]

Travis County will continue to work to provide representation to defendants at Article 15.17 hearings consistent with best practices for judicial proceedings of that nature and the 24 hours a day/7 days a week, 365 days a year schedule of those hearings.  Indigent defense providers may provide representation as part of any tests, trials, pilots, limited or full implementation periods as authorized by Travis County to further the goal of implementing a system of representation at Article 15.17 hearings.  Providers shall notify Travis County Criminal Court Administration of any such implementation periods of representation.

A.        Financial Standards for Determining Indigence

These standards shall apply to each defendant equally, regardless of whether the defendant is in custody or has been released on bail. 

 

B.        Criteria in Determining Indigence

The following criteria as incorporated in the Travis County Indigence Application apply in determining whether a defendant is indigent:                                

1.            The defendant’s annual income

2.            Source of income

3.            Assets

4.            Property owned

5.            Outstanding obligations

6.            Necessary expenses

7.            The number and ages of dependents

8.            Spousal income available to defendant; and

9.            Any other inquiries by a court

10.          Whether the defendant has posted bail shall not be considered, except to the extent that it reflects the defendant’s financial circumstances

 

C.        Presumption of Indigence 

1.            The defendant’s current household income does not exceed the living wage standard established and regularly updated by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's Living Wage Calculator as implemented in the Appendix.

2.            The defendant currently qualifies for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, Medicaid, temporary assistance for needy families, social security assistance or public housing.

3.            The defendant is currently represented by appointed counsel

4.            The defendant has not been able to post bond for at least 2 business days.

5.            The defendant is currently serving a sentence in a correctional facility, mental health institution or other sentence.

 

D.        Judicial Determination of Indigence

A judge may determine that a defendant who does not meet any of the financial standards set forth above is nevertheless indigent if the defendant is otherwise unable to retain private counsel without substantial hardship to the defendant or the defendant’s dependents, taking into account: 

1.            the nature of the criminal charge(s);

2.            the anticipated complexity of the defense;

3.            the estimated cost of obtaining competent legal representation for the matter charged;

4.            and the amount needed for the support of the defendant and the defendant’s dependents. 

 

E.        Process of Determination 

1.            The defendant shall swear under oath before a pretrial officer, clerk or judge that the information provided by the defendant is true.

2.            If a defendant is determined to be indigent, they are presumed to remain indigent for the remainder of the proceedings in the case unless a material change in the defendant’s financial circumstances occurs. 

3.            The defendant’s Indigence Application shall be transmitted to the Travis County Criminal Court Administrator’s Office, (hereinafter referred to as TCCA) no later than 24 hours after the defendant appears before the magistrate.  TCCP Art. 15.17(a).  

 

For the Public Defender's Office (PDO)  - The Chief Public Defender shall establish and maintain the specific attorney qualifications, standards of practice, and caseload standards for all PDO attorneys providing representation to people accused of criminal offenses in Travis County.

For the Mental Health Public Defender's Office (MHPD) - The MHPD Director shall establish and maintain the specific attorney qualifications, standards of practice, and caseload standards for all MHPD attorneys providing representation to people with serious psychiatric diagnoses who are accused of criminal offenses in Travis County.

For Managed Assigned Counsel - The Program Administrator may establish additional criteria to determine which attorneys are qualified to represent persons charged with class A and B misdemeanors, 1st, 2nd, 3rd degree and state jail felonies, as well as appeals.  The qualifications adopted by the Program Administrator shall maintain or exceed the standards that are currently set forth below:

A.        General Minimal Qualifications for CAPDS Attorney Panels

The following standards apply to each attorney who applies to be on the appointment panel and wants to remain on that panel: 

1.            An attorney must have on file with the Program Administrator a completed and sworn application, which is approved by the Review Committee.  Attorneys must ensure all information on their application is correct and current by submission of an electronic oath or by an oath before a notary. 

2.            An attorney must be a licensed practicing attorney and a member in good standing with the State Bar of Texas. 

3.            An attorney must either live in Travis County, or live in an adjoining county and maintain an office within Travis County.  

4.            An attorney must attend any CLE course or training required by the Program Administrator. The program administrator will adopt a minimum number of CLE hours meeting or exceeding 10 hours in the area of criminal law and procedure each year plus one hour of ethics relating to the practice of criminal law. All attorneys on the appointment list must file a CLE report with the Program Administrator each year attesting to completion of this required CLE.  

5.            An attorney must have a secretary, receptionist, answering service, or a cell phone with texting capabilities.  An attorney must have an active e-mail account to receive court appointments and notices regarding procedural changes. An attorney must register a phone number consistent with the requirement above with the Travis County Sheriff to receive calls from incarcerated clients. Attorneys are encouraged to enable the use of video-conferencing. In addition, an attorney must respond promptly (within one business day) to a phone call or text from the court or from the Program Administrator. 

6.            An attorney shall notify the Program Administrator promptly, in writing, of any matter that would disqualify the attorney by law, regulation, and rule or under these guidelines from receiving appointments to represent indigent defendants. 

7.            After approval by the Review Committee, attorneys must attend a general orientation conference regarding the operation of the appointment process and first setting procedures.  Such orientation conference will be provided by the program Administrator at least once a year, and in circumstances where the attorney applying for the panel has known experience and expertise, the conference may be waived by the Program Administrator so that qualified attorneys do not have to wait a year for admittance.

8.            Pursuant to TCCP Article 26.04(j)(4), an attorney shall submit by October 15th of each year a statement that describes the percentage of the attorney's practice time that was dedicated to work based on appointments accepted in this county for adult criminal cases and juvenile delinquency cases for the prior 12 months that begins on October 1 and ends on September 30. The report must be submitted through the online form to the Texas Indigent Defense Commission. 

9.            An attorney must meet other standards adopted by the Program Administrator that do not fall below the standards set forth in this Plan.

  

B.        Minimum Qualifications for CAPDS Misdemeanor Attorney Panels - The following standards apply to each attorney who is appointed to represent a defendant accused of a misdemeanor.

1.            Must meet the General Minimal Qualifications. 

2.            Must have a minimum of one-year work experience in practicing criminal law. 

3.            The evaluation of experience and competency is done when the applicant applies to be on the appointment list and on a periodic basis thereafter.  Factors to be considered are:

a)            Competence, diligence, and skill

b)            Years actively engaged in the practice of criminal law

c)            Certification as a criminal law specialist

d)            Attendance at advanced criminal law courses

e)            Any other special skills 

4.            Must have at least the experience of being lead counsel in 2 misdemeanor jury trials.  Experience as 2nd chair in a felony case may substitute for 1 misdemeanor trial. The styles and cause numbers of these cases should be listed in the attorney’s application. 

5.            Alternatively, attorneys will be qualified for the misdemeanor panel after successful completion of the Capital Area Private Defender Service mentoring program. Attorneys may be assigned misdemeanor cases while in the mentorship program. 

6.            Must have prior appellate experience to be assigned appeals. 

7.            Attorneys on the misdemeanor appointment list may qualify for one or more of the following panels based upon experience and competency: 

a)            Misdemeanor Appointment Panel

b)            Misdemeanor Mental Health Appointment Panel

c)            Misdemeanor Appeal Appointments will be made from the Felony Appellate B Appointment Panel. 

8.            An attorney must meet other experience and competency requirements as deemed appropriate by the Program Administrator that do not fall below the standards set forth in this Plan.

 

C.        Minimum Qualifications for CAPDS Mental Health Attorney Panel - The following standards apply to each attorney who is appointed to represent a defendant on the specialized mental health dockets accused of a criminal offense. 

1.            An attorney must meet the general qualifications. 

2.            An attorney applying for mental health court appointments must have served as a prosecutor in a county or district attorney’s office for at least two years or have practiced criminal defense law on a regular basis for a minimum of two years. 

3.            The evaluation of experience and competency is done when the applicant applies to be on the appointment list and on a periodic basis thereafter.   Factors to be considered are:

a)            Competence, diligence, and skill

b)            Years actively engaged in the practice of criminal law

c)            Certification as a criminal law specialist

d)            Attendance at advanced criminal law courses

e)            Any other special skills
 

4.            An attorney must have been lead counsel in at least 3 mental health cases (whether misdemeanor or felony) with at least one of the following issues presented:  competency, sanity or court ordered mental health treatment.  The styles and cause numbers of these cases must be listed in the appointment application. 

5.            The Program Administrator will adopt minimum training standards in the area of mental health each year. An attorney must have received 3 hours of CLE in mental health criminal issues or received training within 3 months of placement on the mental health appointment list. 

6.            An attorney must be knowledgeable concerning criminal law related to defendants with mental health issues and the Texas Mental Health Code. 

7.            An attorney applying for the misdemeanor mental health court appointment list must meet requirements for placement on the misdemeanor list.

8.            An attorney applying for the felony mental health court appointment list must meet requirements for placement on the Category B felony list.

9.            An attorney must meet other experience, training, and competency requirements as deemed appropriate by the Program Administrator that do not fall below the standards set forth in this Plan.

 

D.        Minimum Qualifications for Felony CAPDS Attorney Panel - The following standards apply to each attorney who is appointed to represent a defendant accused of a felony. 

1.            An attorney must meet the general qualifications.

2.            An attorney must have served as a prosecutor in a county or district attorney's office for at least two years or have practiced criminal defense law on a regular basis for a minimum of two years.

3.            An attorney must have been lead counsel in at least 3 misdemeanor jury trials or first or second chair in at least two felony jury trials.  The styles and cause numbers of these cases must be listed in attorney’s application.

4.            Attorneys on the felony appointment list may qualify for one or more of the following panels based upon experience and competency:

a)            Felony A Appointment Panel

b)            Felony B Appointment Panel

c)            Felony C Appointment Panel

d)            Felony Mental Health Appointment Panel

e)            Felony Appellate A Panel

f)             Felony Appellate B Panel is also utilized to appoint misdemeanor appeals.

 

5.            The evaluation of experience and competency is done when the applicant applies to be on the appointment list and on a periodic basis thereafter.  Factors to be considered are:

a)            Competence, diligence, and skill

b)            Years actively engaged in the practice of criminal law

c)            Certification as a criminal law specialist

d)            Attendance at advanced criminal law courses

e)            Any other special skills

 

6.            Other experience and competency as deemed appropriate by the Program Administrator that do not fall below the standards set forth in this Plan

7.            Alternatively, attorneys may qualify for a felony panel after successful completion of the Capital Area Private Defender Service felony mentoring program. While in the mentoring program attorneys may receive felony cases with the assistance of their mentor attorney and at the direction of the Program Administrator. Before admittance to any panel through the felony mentorship program, the felony mentoring program must be approved by the Travis County District Court Judges.

 

E.        Types of Felony Panels: 

1.            Capital Cases: Attorneys will qualify and receive appointments pursuant to TCCP Article 26.052 and are subject to the Third Judicial Region’s Capital Attorney Selection Committee's rules and procedures.  

2.            A Panel: Attorneys must have significant experience with all phases of a criminal practice including aggravated and first degree felony jury trials as lead counsel; very knowledgeable concerning criminal law and procedure, and a capable trial attorney. Attorneys must meet general qualifications and have completed, as lead counsel, at least two first degree felony jury trials to be considered for this panel. 

3.            B Panel:  Attorneys must have experience trying misdemeanor and some felony trials to a jury and before the court and second-chairing serious felony cases; experience trying other contested matters such as felony pre-trials and probation revocations; capable and knowledgeable but lacking experience in serious/aggravated felony cases. Attorneys must meet general qualifications and have completed, as lead counsel, at least one felony jury trial. 

4.            C Panel: Knowledgeable concerning criminal law and procedure and possessing trial skills but lacking significant felony trial experience, some jury trial experience in misdemeanors and, at least as second chair, in felonies.

 

F.        Minimum Qualifications of Appellate Attorneys

The following standards apply to each attorney who is appointed to represent a defendant in an appeal. 

1.            Appellate A Panel: Attorneys placed on this list must have prior experience in felony level appellate work. At least two prior felony appellate briefs, along with any other requested data shall be submitted for review. The brief submission requirement contemplates the submission of a fully developed brief. An Anders brief alone will NOT satisfy the brief submission requirement. The complexity of the appellate work done will be a factor in determining eligibility and placement on the A level appellate list. 

 2.          Appellate B Panel: Attorneys placed on this list must have experience in appellate work at the misdemeanor, class A or B levels.  At the time of application, a brief evidencing prior appellate experience shall be submitted for review with any other relevant information.

 3.            Alternatively, attorneys may qualify for each appellate panel after successful completion of the Capital Area Private Defender Service mentoring program. While in the mentoring program attorneys may receive appellate cases with the assistance of their mentor attorney and at the direction of the Program Administrator. Before admittance to any panel through the mentorship program, the mentoring program must be approved by the Travis County District Court judges.

G.       Minimum Qualifications for CAPDS Magistration Attorney Panel

The Program Administrator shall estabilsh standards necessary to ensure qualified attorneys represent a defendant at first appearance (magistration).

1.           These standards may be less than those to qualify for full admission so long as attorneys completed all training required by the Program Administrator specific to representation at magistration.

2.           Admission to the magistration panel shall be at the discretion of the Executive Director and is subject to review by the Review Committee.

H.       Determining Qualification 

1.            The Program Administrator through its Review Committee will determine the appropriate panel placement for each attorney.

 

I.        Duties of Newly Appointed Attorneys 

1.            An attorney is notified of an appointment by e-mail. The attorney shall, within three working days of receiving notice of appointment, enter into the Assignment Management Portal (“AMP”), an internet based application, an acknowledgment of the appointment and a confirmation that the attorney made a reasonable effort to contact the defendant by the end of the first working day after the date of the appointment.  Reasonable effort includes letter, fax, phone, video conferenceone, or a personal visit.  Text messages alone are not considered a reasonable effort. 

2.            In felony cases, court appointed attorneys must visit all appointed clients incarcerated at the Travis County jail in person (or utilize videoconferencing) at the earliest possible time and that initial visit shall not be later than ten days from notification of assignment. This visit shall be noted in AMP by the attorney within three working days. 

3.            In misdemeanor cases, court appointed attorneys must visit all appointed clients incarcerated at the Travis County jail in person (or utilize videoconferencing) at the earliest possible time and that initial visit shall not be later than five days from notification of assignment.  This visit must be noted in AMP by the attorney within three working days. 

4.            Additionally, duties of assigned counsel shall include:

a)            Make every reasonable effort to:

(1)          Contact the client by the end of the first working day after the date on which the attorney is appointed; and

(2)          Interview the client as soon as practicable after the attorney is appointed, but not later than the requirements mandated by this Plan;

b)            Represent the client until:

(1)          Charges are dismissed;

(2)          The client is acquitted;

(3)          Appeals are exhausted; or

(4)          The attorney is relieved of his duties by the court or Program Administrator. Program Administrator may relieve an attorney with good cause if the case is not on the jury docket. If the case is on the jury docket, the Judge may relieve an attorney. 

c)            Where appropriate, an attorney has an obligation to secure release of the client through conditions most favorable to the client. 

d)            Investigate, either by self or through an investigator, the facts of the case and be prepared to present any factual defense(s) that may be reasonably and arguably available to the client; 

e)            Brief the law of the case, file appropriate motions, and be prepared to present any legal defense(s) that may be reasonably and arguably available to the client; 

f)             Be prepared to negotiate with the prosecutor for the most favorable resolution of the case as can be achieved through a plea agreement; 

g)            Be prepared to try the case to conclusion either with or without a jury; 

h)            Be prepared to file post-trial motions, give notice of appeal and appeal the case pursuant to the standards and requirements of the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure; 

i)             Maintain reasonable communication and contact with the client at all times and keep the client informed of the status of the case, preferably by in person visits; 

j)             Advise the client on all matters involving the case and such collateral matters as may reasonably be required to aid the client in making appropriate decisions about the case. 

k)            Perform the attorney’s duty owed to the client in accordance with these procedures, the requirements of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and applicable rules of ethics; and 

l)             Manage attorney’s workload to allow for the provision of quality representation and the execution of the responsibilities listed in these rules in every case.

  

J.         Suspension or Removal of Attorney from Appointment List and Readmission to List

1.            General Competence/Review by Program Administrator. 

a)         Appointed attorneys are reviewed annually by the Program Administrator through its Review Committee.  The judges shall submit an annual evaluation of all appointed attorneys to the Review Committee.  These evaluations will be used in the Review Committee’s assessment of each attorney’s performance.  The District Judges will evaluate the felony list attorneys and the County Court at Law Judges will evaluate the misdemeanor list attorneys.  Each judge will evaluate each attorney’s performance and indicate whether the attorney:  exceeds expectations, meets expectations, or is below expectations.

 b)            General Criteria

(1)          Efficiency:

(a)          Punctuality-Court appearances, motions, briefs, etc.

(b)          Preparation in all areas

(c)           Efficient use of court time

(2)          Knowledge:

(a)          Knowledge of individual court’s rules and procedures

(b)          Knowledge of Criminal Law

(c)           Knowledge of Criminal Procedures

(d)          Knowledge of probation programs, sentencing options, etc.

(3)          Skill:

(a)          Ability to communicate and conduct business with Judges, court staff, and district/county attorney in a civil and effective manner

(b)          Ability to deal effectively with clients

(c)           Ability to present legal arguments to court

(d)          Ability to examine witnesses, present objections and perform jury trial skills.

(4)          Ethics:

(a)          Follows rules of professional conduct

(b)          Honesty in dealings with court, other attorneys, staff, and clients

 

c)            TCCA will assist in compiling the judicial evaluations and will forward the reviews to the Program Administrator.  At the judges’ discretion judicial evaluations may be anonymous.  An attorney who receives at least two “below expectations” ratings from the judges will be presented to the Review Committee for review.  A majority of the Review Committee shall vote to take one of the following actions:

(1)          remove the attorney from the appointments list; or

(2)          communicate observations and concerns through the Review Committee Chairman or the CAPDS Director on behalf of the body of judges to the attorney; or

(3)          place the attorney on a lower list (felony appointments only); or

(4)          place the attorney on probation for a specific period.

 

d)            Terms and period of a probation term will be defined and communicated by the Program Administrator to the attorney.  Attorneys placed on probation, may re-apply at the expiration of the probationary period, and the Review Committee will re-evaluate the attorney’s performance.  A majority of the Review Committee shall vote to either: 

(1)          remove the attorney from probation; or

(2)          suspend the attorney from the list for a longer period; or

(3)          place the attorney on a lower list (felony appointments only)

 

e)            If the Review Committee votes to impose a sanction, the Program Administrator shall communicate the attorney’s status and any other information relevant thereto as provided by the Review Committee.

 

f)             In the event an attorney is incapacitated physically, mentally, or otherwise, in such a way as to call into question their ability to provide adequate representation, the attorney’s level of proficiency may be reviewed by the Program Administrator through its Review Committee. 

(a)          The Review Committee may vote to reduce the attorney’s classification to a lower level or remove the attorney from the list.  A majority vote is required to remove or reclassify an attorney.  The notice for an attorney to meet with the Program Administrator shall generally inform the attorney of the areas of deficiencies.

(b)          A mentor may be appointed by the Program Administrator and/or Review Committee from a list of mentors which are approved by the Program Administrator.

(c)           If an attorney is removed from the list or reclassified to a lower level, the Program Administrator shall communicate the attorney’s status and any other information relevant thereto as provided by the Review Committee.

 

g)            If an attorney is held to have rendered ineffective assistance of counsel by a court of record, and all appeals from said holding have been exhausted, the Program Administrator may remove the attorney from the appointment list for a minimum of one year.  The attorney may reapply for the appointment lists at the end of the suspension period. If an attorney is removed from the list due to this provision, Program Administrator shall inform the attorney of the specific period of removal upon the rendering of the final judgment in the case.

 

h)            The Program Administrator shall have the authority to limit the number of attorneys on the appointments list, at all levels, to maintain the integrity of the process, insure adequate representation of all indigent defendants, and to comply with all requisite legal standards designed to insure appropriate and competent representation of all defendants inclusive of all ABA standards.

 

i)             All unexcused absences from court and failures to visit clients in a timely fashion should be reported to the Program Administrator so the office can maintain a cumulative record for all district and county courts at law.  When the Program Administrator observes a recurring problem with an attorney it should be brought to the Review Committee's attention at the earliest appropriate time.  The Review Committee will take appropriate action, to include written warning, probation or suspension under these rules and report the action taken to the criminal court judges within weeks of said action.

 

j)             The Program Administrator shall have the authority to adopt other standards and review procedures as the Program Administrator deems necessary that do not fall below the standards set forth in this Plan.

 

2.            Specific Incidents of Misconduct Observed by or Reported to a Judge -  If a judge experiences a specific problem with an attorney such as failure to attend court in a punctual manner, failure to timely visit clients, or other unethical or improper conduct, the judge may request an investigation by the Program Administrator.

 a)            If the matter is not resolved to the judge’s satisfaction or the judge determines that the nature or circumstances of the conduct is sufficiently serious, the judge may request that Program Administrator immediately suspend the attorney from the appointment list. 

b)            The Program Administrator shall suspend the attorney and immediately notify him/her of said suspension.  The notice shall further inform the attorney of the grounds for suspension and that the attorney has 7 days from date of notice to file a written response with the Program Administrator. 

c)            The Program Administrator shall circulate any response to all Review Committee Members and the suspension shall be voted on by the Review Committee at its next regular meeting.   The judges will make a recommendation to the Program Administrator.  Three or more votes ratify the suspension, which shall remain in effect until a majority of the Review Committee votes to return the attorney to the list.

 

3.         Specific Incidents of Misconduct Observed by Program Administrator - If the Program Administrator becomes aware of actions by assigned counsel that require review by the Review Committee, the Executive Director may suspend an attorney for up to fifteen days and shall refer the case to the Review Committee. If the Review Committee does not have a regularly scheduled meeting within fifteen days, the Executive Director may renew the period of suspension for an additional thirty days.

 

4.         Attorney Sanctions Pursuant to the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure - Disciplinary sanctions imposed pursuant to the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure may constitute grounds for suspension or removal from the appointment list.

a)            If an attorney receives a disciplinary sanction pursuant to the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, other than a private reprimand, the attorney shall provide to Program Administrator a copy of the order imposing sanction within 30 days of the said order. 

b)            An attorney may provide a written supplement of the disciplinary sanction when providing the order imposing sanctions. 

c)            Program Administrator shall circulate the order imposing sanctions and the written supplement to the review committee and the judges.  The vote of a majority the Review Committee is required to suspend or remove the attorney from the appointment list.

d)            Failure to provide a copy of the order imposing a disciplinary sanction pursuant to the Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure to Program Administrator within 30 days of the entry of said order may constitute independent grounds for removal from the appointment list.

 

5.         Readmission to List -  An attorney suspended from the list may reapply after 1 year.  The new application may contain any information the attorney deems relevant to readmission.  The request should be submitted in writing to the Program Administrator. A majority vote of the Review Committee is required to reinstate an attorney.

 

6.         Appellate Issues - Late Briefs

a)            An appellate attorney who receives notice from an appellate court that the deadline for filing a brief has not been met, shall immediately notify Program Administrator.  The attorney shall be temporarily suspended from the appellate appointment list until the appellate brief has been filed.  Once it has been filed with the appropriate court, a written or electronic copy of the brief and proof of filing must be provided to Program Administrator and to the presiding judge of the court wherein the case originated.

 b)            An appellate attorney who receives an order to show cause why they should not be held in contempt for failure to timely file a brief, or the appeal is abated to determine whether the defendant still wishes to pursue the appeal after appellate counsel has failed to respond to notice from an appellate court that his brief is overdue, shall be permanently removed from the appellate appointment lists. An attorney so removed may apply for immediate reinstatement to the appellate appointment list by submitting proof of exceptional circumstances which reasonably prevented the attorney from responding to the notice of the brief being overdue.  A majority vote of the Review Committee is required for such immediate reinstatement.  Alternatively, the attorney may re-apply for the appellate appointment list at the next open application period, and include a statement of steps the attorney has taken to prevent a future recurrence of failure to timely file a brief.

 c)            These rules apply to all appeals by attorneys on the appointment list, without regard to whether the subject case is being handled by appointment or otherwise.    A judge who receives notice of the above facts will notify the Program Administrator immediately.

 

7.        Maximum Caseload Limits

a)           The Program Administrator will develop and implement weighted-caseload controls based on the TIDC Guidelines for Indigent Defense Caseloads and in accordance with the TIDC Grant Statement Award.

b)           An attorney receiving assignments in excess of the weighted caseload will be suspended from new assignments until such time as the attorney is no longer over the guidelines.

c)           The Program Administrator may adopt policies and procedures necessary to implement weighted-caseload controls.

d)           The Program Administrator may adopt additional standards that meet or exceed this standard. 

  

8.         Temporary Inactive Status

 a)            Temporary Inactive Status During Death Penalty Trials. Attorneys who are court appointed to represent defendants charged with capital murder in which the death penalty is sought will be temporarily inactivated on the felony appointment list starting 30 days before the beginning of voir dire and lasting for the duration of the case. The Program Administrator may adopt additional standards that meet or exceed this standard.

 b)            Temporary Inactive Status during Voluntary Leave. An attorney may request to be inactive for up to 90 days by submitting a written request to the Program Administrator.  If an attorney has been inactive on the court appointment list for more than 90 days, they must submit a written request to reinstate along with proof of CLE compliance to the Program Administrator. The Program Administrator will decide if the attorney will be reinstated.

 

9.         Attorneys on Appointment List(s) Charged with Criminal Offenses

 a)            An attorney shall be automatically suspended from all court appointment lists if they are convicted of or receives a deferred adjudication sentence for any felony or crime of moral turpitude.

 b)            An attorney shall be automatically suspended from the misdemeanor appointment list if they are charged with a class A or B misdemeanor offense which is being prosecuted by the Travis County Attorney’s Office and from the felony appointment list if they are charged with a felony offense which is being prosecuted by the Travis County District Attorney’s Office.

 c)            An attorney may be suspended from the appointment list if they are under indictment or other formal criminal charge for any offense if a majority of the Review Committee determines that the attorney’s ability to fully and effectively represent their appointed clients is compromised or otherwise adversely affected by the pending charge.

 d)            Within seven (7) days of any suspension under this section the attorney shall notify their court appointed clients of the suspension and that the client may petition the Program Administrator or the trial court for the appointment of another attorney.

 e)            An attorney who is charged with a crime and released on a bond to be supervised by the Office of Pretrial Services must obtain the services of another attorney to deal with any matters involving his clients and the Office of Pretrial Services.

 f)             An attorney shall notify the Program Administrator in writing within 2 business days after being arrested for and/or charged with a class A or B misdemeanor or any felony offense.

 g)            An attorney may seek reinstatement to the appointment list when:

(1)          the charges have been dismissed;

(2)          the charges have not resulted in an indictment or other formal accusation within sixty days of arrest; or,

(3)          any sentence or probation is completed.

 

10.      Attorneys on List Accepting Remuneration from Appointed Clients 

a)            An attorney appointed to represent a client is not allowed to solicit or accept remuneration from the client on the appointed case(s) unless the Program Administrator determines that there has been a change in status and approves such payment.   

b)            If the client is charged with new offenses or is in need of other legal services during the pendency of his appointed case(s), the appointed attorney cannot accept remuneration for representation in those matters without notice to, and approval by Program Administrator.

A.        Defendants Arrested in Travis County

1.            On a daily basis, TCCA staff will obtain the completed Indigence Applications from the Office of Pretrial Services. The TCCA through an electronic software program will appoint the Public Defender's Office, the Mental Health Public Defender's Office, or counsel from the lists provided by the CAPDS Program Administrator. Appointments will be made no later than the end of the first working day after the date on which TCCA receives the defendant’s request for counsel.

2.            A magistrate or judge will advise unrepresented defendants of the right to counsel and procedures for obtaining counsel according to CCP Article 1.051(f2). 

3.            If a defendant wishes to request counsel prior to the initial appearance, the form required to request counsel may be obtained from the Travis County Criminal Courts' website at:  https://www.traviscountytx.gov/images/courts/Docs/indigence.pdf.  Defendants may submit these forms to the court staff in which they have been directed to appear. The court will rule on all requests for counsel submitted in this manner. [1TAC 174.51]

B.        Defendants Not Arrested and Out of Custody with An Active Warrant

           1.           Defendants who have not been arrested but know they have a warrant may contact CAPDS or the Public Defender's Office.  Those Offices may direct the defendant to fill out the indigence form from Pretrial Services which should direct the person to TCCA where they can be appointed the next attorney ready to receive an assignment if they qualify.

C.        Out of County Arrests and Warrants

1.            Defendants arrested in other counties on local warrants must be appointed counsel within one working day of receipt of the request.

2.            Defendants arrested on out-of-county warrants must be appointed counsel if the person has not been transferred or released to the custody of the county issuing the warrant before the 11th day after the date of the arrest. [Art. 1.05(c-1), CCP]

3.            Pretrial Services Staff will provide reasonable assistance filling out the indigence screening to defendants incarcerated on out-of-county warrants requesting court appointed counsel.  Results of the screening will be transmitted via facsimile or email to the county of the originating warrant within 24 hours of request.   [1TAC § 174.51]

D.        Procedures for Appointment of Counsel - Pursuant to TCCP Articles 26.04, Court Administration facilitates the appointment of counsel to indigent criminal defendants through:

 1.           TCCP Article 26.04 (f-1) - Managed Assigned Counsel:  Capital Area Private Defender Service.  Pursuant to the TCCP Articles 26.04 (a), 26.04 (f-1) and 26.047 the Criminal Court Judges by majority vote authorized the presiding Criminal Court Judge to petition the Travis County Commissioners Court to apply for a grant from the Texas Indigent Defense Commission to help implement a Managed Assigned Counsel Program to administer court appointed criminal cases assigned to the Travis County District and County Courts.  The Austin Bar Association and the Austin Criminal Defense Lawyers Association created the Capital Area Private Defender Service (CAPDS), a non-profit corporation whose purpose is to manage court appointed cases in accordance with this plan.  CAPDS shall serve as the Program Administrator for The Plan.

CAPDS shall incorporate the rules of the Plan into its Plan of Operation in order to meet or exceed the standards for indigent defense and to be in compliance wtih the Fair Defense Act of 2001.  CAPDS shall manage approved appointed attorney appearing in the Travis County Criminal County Courts at Law and the Criminal District Courts.  Each attorney accepted to provide legal representation under this Plan shall be provided a copy of these rules and procedures by the MAC.

           2.           TCCP Article 26.04 (f) - Public Defender Offices

                          a)  Travis County Mental Health Public Defender (MHPD) - (see attachment for Policies and Procedures Related to Legal Representation).

                          b)  Travis County Public Defender's Office (PDO) - (see attachment for Case Representation & Caseload Management Practices and Policies incorporating the Texas Indigent Defense Commission's (TIDC) FY20 Statement of Grant Award detailing the PDO's creation, goals, objections, staffing, evaluation and funding).

           3.           TCCP Article 26.052 (c) - Local Selection Committee for Capital Appointments:  Third Judicial Region's Capital Attorney Selection Committee.

 

A.        PDO Attorney Assignment Process

          1.          The Public Defender's Office shall be eligible for all non-capital trial-level appointments within the County's electronic appointment system and shall have priority for appointments consistent with its representation capacity, except in mental health cases where the Mental Health Public Defender shall have priority consistent with its representation capacity for misdemeanors, state jail, and 3rd degree felonies. 

          2.           The Public Defender's Office, through the Chief Public Defender, will determine its representation capacity consistent with TCCP Article 26.044 and Case Representation & Caseload Management Practices and Policies.  In accordance with the TIDC Statement of Grant Award, the Chief Public Defender shall have access to the appointment system to be able to enter the PDO's capacity and govern the office's workload.

         3.           Upon accepting an appointment, the Chief Public Defender, or their designee, shall be responsible for assignments to individual PDO attorneys, taking into consideration the experience, skills, and training of all attorneys, individual and office-wide caseloads, and any other consideration relevant to an attorney's duty to provide competent, diligent, and zealous advocacy.

          4.           A judge may remove a PDO attorney from a case pursuant to TCCP Article 26.044(k) or at the request of the accused upon their motion for new counsel indicating an irreparable breakdown in the client-attorney relationship.

B.         MHPD Attorney Assignment Process

      1.      The MHPD shall be eligible for appointments in all trial level misdemeanors, state jail, and 3rd degree felony cases, in which the individual meets the criteria for MHPD representation detailed in the office's Policies and Procedures Related to Legal Representation.  Consistent  with their representation capacity, the MHPD shall have priority for appointment in these cases.

          2.          The MHPD, through the MHPD Director, will determine its representation capacity consistent with TCCP Article 26.044 and the office's Policies and Procedures Related to Legal Representation.

        3.         Upon accepting an appointment, the MHPD Director, or their designee, shall be responsible for assignments to individual MHPD attorneys, taking into consideration the experience, skills, and training of all attorneys, individual and office-wide caseloads, and any  other consideration relevant to an attorney's duty to provide competent, diligent, and zealous advocacy.  

C.         CAPDS Attorney Assignment Process

 1.            The Program Administrator will identify which of the appointment panels (discussed above re: attorney qualifications) is most appropriate for each attorney based on the accusations against the defendant and the level of experience of each attorney.

 2.            The Judge, TCCA Staff, or the Program Administrator will appoint an attorney pursuant to the qualifications adopted by the Program Administrator.

 3.            The currently approved panels are:

a)            Misdemeanor Panel:  Attorneys approved for the misdemeanor list may be appointed to Class A and B misdemeanors.

b)            Misdemeanor Mental Health Panel:   Attorneys approved for the misdemeanor mental health list may be appointed to any level of misdemeanor selected for the mental health docket.

c)            A Felony Panel:   Only attorneys who are placed on the A List shall be assigned to any cases (including but not limited to motions to proceed with an adjudication of guilt/motions to revoke probation and mental health cases) wherein the maximum sentence does not exceed life, or 99 years in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. This category includes 1st degree, 2nd degree, 3rd degree and state jail felony offenses as well as habitual offenders and enhanced punishment ranges.

d)            B Felony Panel:  Attorneys who are placed on the B list shall be assigned to all cases (including but not limited to motions to proceed with an adjudication of guilt and motions to revoke probation) wherein the maximum sentence does not exceed 20 years.  This category includes 2nd degree, 3rd degree and state jail felony offenses.

e)            C Felony Panel:  Attorneys will be assigned to state jail felonies and motions to adjudicate and motions to revoke state jail felonies.

f)             Felony Mental Health Panel:  Attorneys approved for the felony mental health list may be appointed to any level of felony selected for the mental health docket.

g)            A Appellate Panel will be assigned appeals from non-death capital cases, 1st degree felony cases, and those cases involving habitual or 1st degree punishment ranges.  An attorney on this list may be appointed to any felony appeal (except a death penalty case).

h)            B Appellate Panel will be assigned appeal from felony cases of a 2nd degree level or lower.

 

4.            The Program Administrator may assign second-chairs pursuant to the Policy and Procedures of the Program Administrator. 

5.            Program Administrator shall solicit applications for new and status change attorneys at any time deemed appropriate by the Program Administrator. Deadlines and admission requirements shall be published in advance of the Review Committee’s decision date.   The Program Administrator may admit highly qualified attorneys to the list outside the open enrollment period for exceptional circumstances as determined by a majority vote of the Review Committee. 

6.            Appointments shall be made using a rotation system.  TCCA makes all reasonable efforts to provide Spanish speaking attorneys to Spanish speaking clients, but if not available, an attorney will be provided with interpretation services at County expense.  All limited English proficiency persons will be provided interpretation services as constitutionally required and in accordance with the Courts' LEP plan:  Language Access Plan (traviscountytx.gov) 

7.            Appointments for Spanish speaking cases shall be made using a separate rotation system following an alphabetical listing of the names of attorneys eligible to receive Spanish-speaking clients.  

8.            Appointments for mental health cases shall be made using a separate rotation system.  Priority appointment will be given to the Mental Health Public Defender Office in misdemeanors, state jail, and 3rd degree felonies, according to their representation capacity.  Then eligible panel attorneys will be appointed following an alphabetical listing of their names. 

9.            A judge may deviate from a rotation system when the judge finds it is in the best interests of all parties concerned.  The judge making such appointment shall make a finding setting forth the reason for such appointment in compliance with TCCP, Article 26.04 and will notify Program Administrator of the appointment. 

10.          The presiding judge over a criminal case and the Program Administrator have the power to remove appointed counsel.  The Program Administrator may remove appointed counsel upon a finding of good cause for such removal including but not limited to the following:  

a)            Counsel’s failure to appear in a court hearing;

b)            Counsel’s failure to comply with the requirements of this Plan or the Program Administrator’s written policies;

c)            Current information about the defendant and the charges against the defendant indicate that another qualified attorney is more appropriate for the defendant under these rules;

d)            The appointed counsel shows good cause for being removed, such as illness, workload or schedule difficulties;

e)            The defendant requests an attorney other than trial counsel, for appeal; or

f)             The defendant shows good cause for removal of counsel, including counsel’s persistent or prolonged failure to communicate with the defendant. 

11.          In misdemeanor cases, a joint bond review docket will be held daily by the county courts at law.  Appointments will be made on a rotating basis, in alphabetical order.  Cases in which the attorney does not appear will be reappointed in court from the alphabetical rotation.  

12.          In felony cases, an attorney may receive an appointment for the highest level of offense for which they are qualified and for any lower level offense in which they havequalified.  If a case is enhanced above an attorney’s qualified level, the attorney shall notify the court or Program Administrator immediately, to ensure the appropriate level attorney is assigned. 

13.          Program Administrator will maintain all records on attorneys, and provide orientation training. 

In consideration of reasonable compensation for court appointed counsel, taking into account necessary overhead costs and availability of qualified attorneys willing to accept the stated rates, the following guidelines shall be used to claim attorney’s fees for appointed counsel, except for an attorney with the Public Defender's Office or the Mental Health Public Defender's Office, in felony and misdemeanor criminal cases pursuant to the TCCP, Article 26.05.

A.        Compensation Rates and Requests for Payment. Schedules are set for in Appendix, as follows:

1.            Travis County Fee Guidelines for Appointed Counsel in Misdemeanor Criminal Cases

2.            Travis County Fee Guidelines for Appointed Counsel in Felony Criminal Cases

B.        Expenses

1.            Appointed counsel will be compensated for all necessary expenses, i.e., long distance telephone charges, copying expenses, auto mileage (IRS rate) outside of Travis County.

2.            All major expenses, such as investigators and expert witnesses, will require written approval by the Program Administrator prior to the expense being incurred.

3.            Expenses incurred without prior Program Administrator’s approval will not automatically be reimbursed.  Such expenses shall be reimbursed if the Program Administrator determines that they are reasonably necessary and reasonably incurred upon presentation of a claim for reimbursement.

C.        Request for Payment

1.            Appointed counsel shall present completed vouchers for their work to the Program Administrator for approval according to the fee schedules adopted by the District and County Court at Law Judges.  Vouchers must be presented timely, but in no case shall the presentation of the voucher exceed two years after the representation ends.  

2.            No payment shall be made until the form for itemizing the services performed is submitted to the Program Administrator over the proceedings and the Program Administrator approves the payment.

D.        Appeal of payment amount

1.            An attorney whose request for payment is disapproved is entitled to a copy of the Program Administrator’s findings for approving an amount different from the requested amount.

2.            The attorney may appeal the disapproval by filing a motion with the presiding Judge of the Administrative Judicial Region, as provided in TCCP Article 26.05(c).

 

 

 

Travis District and County Court 2023 Living Wage Calculator for Indigence Determination.pdf (10/27/2023 1:46:01 PM) view
Travis District and County Court Affidavit of Indigence.pdf (1/22/2021 12:57:36 PM) view
Travis District and County Court Attorney Fee Schedule.pdf (10/27/2023 1:36:53 PM) view
Travis District and County Court CAPDS Fee Voucher.County.pdf (1/6/2015 11:17:41 AM) view
Travis District and County Court CAPDS Fee Voucher.District.pdf (1/6/2015 11:18:15 AM) view
Travis District and County Court Contracts for Indigent Defense Services.pdf (1/6/2015 11:16:35 AM) view
Travis District and County Court Exigent Circumstances Order.pdf (10/21/2015 9:04:26 AM) view
Travis District and County Court Managed Assigned Counsel Plan of Operation.pdf (1/6/2015 11:16:03 AM) view
Travis District and County Court PD Case Representation & Caseload Management Practices & Policies.pdf (1/22/2021 12:50:53 PM) view
Travis District and County Court Public Defender Plan or Proposal.pdf (8/30/2018 3:00:40 PM) view
Travis District and County Court Standards for Admittance to the CAPDS Panels.pdf (1/6/2015 11:23:12 AM) view